CO2 laser ablation of oropharyngeal dysplasia

The use of CO₂laser in the management of oral dysplastic lesions have been put into practice for more than a few years now. The main advantage is the decrease in local tissue morbidity. Very few studies have evaluated recurrence, malignant transformation and overall outcome in patients undergoing such procedure.

In this prospective study, a total of 123 oral dysplastic lesions from 77 consecutive patients were treated with CO₂laser (resection and/or ablation). The average age was 58±4.8 years. Patients’ recovery was uneventful and no complications reported. Comparisons with the clinical and histopathological features and rate of recurrence as well as malignant transformation were made. These patients were followed-up for a mean of 6.4 years, and biopsies taken in case of changes indicative of malignant development.

The results were analysed by an independent statistician using SPSS 17. The results were cross tabulated and the Chi-squared statistic was used to test for differences in the case-mix.

Homogenous leukoplakias were identified in 31 patients, non-homogenous leukoplakias in 34 patients, whereas 12 patients had erythroplakias. Ex- and lifelong smokers formed 88.3% of the recruited patients. While people who currently smoke and drink formed 55.8% (43 patients) of the cohort. Erythroplakias were solely identified in heavy lifelong smokers. The most common identified primary anatomical locations were the lateral border of tongue, floor of mouth and buccal mucosa. Moderate dysplasia was identified in 42 patients while 18 patients had severe dysplasias.

Laser resection margins in selected cases (68 patients) were clear in 53 and showed mild-moderate dysplasia in the involved margins. The rate of recurrence had no significant association with the location or the severity of epithelial dysplasia. The rate of first recurrence in laser surgery was approximately 19.5%. Malignant transformation was observed in 8 patients (10.4%), in the tongue and the floor of mouth. Recurrence and malignant transformation was mainly identified in erythroplakias and non-homogenous leukoplakias.

Recurrence and/or malignant transformation of oral dysplasia have been observed following laser surgery. Laser resection/ablation is recommended for oral dysplasia to prevent not only recurrence and malignant transformation, but also postoperative oral dysfunction encountered by other conventional modalities. In this study, smoking and drinking were associated with oral erythroplakia formation; the latter was identified to recur and transform into squamous cell carcinoma more than other lesions.

Affiliations

1. UCL Department of Surgery, University College London Medical School, London, UK
   • Waseem Jerjes
   • , Tahwinder Upile
   • , Zaid Hamdoon
   •  & Colin Hopper

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Waseem Jerjes.

Reprints and Permissions